A longstanding constitutional challenge to Canada’s Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA) with the United States has returned to the Federal Court. Hearings began in Toronto on November 9, 2026, with applicants arguing that returning certain refugee claimants to the United States violates their equality rights under Section 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
The case has been brought by Amnesty International Canada, the Canadian Council for Refugees and the Canadian Council of Churches, together with former refugee claimants. The applicants argue that the agreement has a disproportionate impact on racialized women, LGBTQI+ people and children, who may face particular risks in the U.S. asylum and immigration detention systems.
The proceedings are significant for refugee protection and Canada’s obligations under the Charter. However, the hearing itself does not change the current operation of the agreement. The STCA remains in effect while the constitutional challenge is considered.
What is the Canada-U.S. Safe Third Country Agreement?
Canada and the United States signed the Safe Third Country Agreement in December 2002, and it came into effect on December 29, 2004. The agreement is based on the principle that people seeking refugee protection should generally make their claim in the first safe country they reach.
Under the agreement, most people who seek refugee protection at an official Canada-U.S. land border crossing are returned to the United States to pursue their claim there, unless they qualify for an applicable exception.
In March 2023, the agreement was expanded to cover the entire land border, including internal waterways. It also applies to certain people who cross between official ports of entry and make a refugee claim within 14 days of entering Canada.
The agreement includes exceptions relating to family members in Canada, unaccompanied minors, certain document holders and public interest circumstances. Meeting an STCA exception does not automatically establish eligibility for refugee protection. Claimants must still satisfy the other requirements of Canada’s immigration and refugee legislation.
What are the applicants arguing in the Charter challenge?
The applicants are challenging the constitutionality of returning certain refugee claimants to the United States under the STCA. Their central argument is that the agreement’s application can have discriminatory effects on particular groups, including racialized women, LGBTQI+ individuals and children.
They argue that some people returned to the United States may face detention, inadequate protection or the risk of being sent to countries where they could experience persecution or other serious harm.
The applicants are asking the Federal Court to find that the designation of the United States as a safe third country violates Section 15 of the Charter, which protects equality rights. They are seeking to have that designation struck down.
These are the applicants’ legal arguments, not findings already made by the court. The Federal Court will have to consider the evidence and legal submissions before reaching a decision.
Source: Historic Charter challenge to the Safe Third Country Agreement is in court
Why is the case returning to the Federal Court?
The constitutional challenge has been before Canadian courts for several years. In 2023, the Supreme Court of Canada addressed an earlier stage of the litigation and returned the Section 15 equality questions to the Federal Court for consideration.
The current hearings are therefore part of the continuing legal process rather than a newly filed challenge. The applicants are asking the Federal Court to examine the equality implications of the agreement in light of the evidence presented.
Hearings were scheduled for November 9, 10 and 12, with a further hearing date on December 16, 2026. The court’s consideration of the case should not be confused with a final ruling on the agreement’s constitutionality.
Does the legal challenge change the STCA rules for refugee claimants?
No. The agreement remains in effect while the case proceeds.
According to Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada, people entering Canada from the United States along the land border are generally returned to the U.S. unless they meet one of the relevant exemptions or exceptions. The agreement also continues to apply to qualifying crossings between official ports of entry.
The existing exceptions include:
- Family member exception: Certain claimants with qualifying family members in Canada may be eligible.
- Unaccompanied minors exception: Specific protections apply to eligible children travelling without a parent or legal guardian.
- Document holder exception: Certain people holding valid Canadian documents, such as qualifying visas or permits, may fall within an exception.
- Public interest exception: Specific circumstances, including cases involving potential exposure to the death penalty, may be considered.
The precise requirements are set out in Canada’s official STCA guidance. Claimants should not assume that an exception applies without reviewing their individual circumstances and the relevant legal requirements.
What could happen if the court rules in favour of the applicants?
If the Federal Court finds that the challenged designation violates Section 15 of the Charter, the ruling could have significant implications for how Canada applies the agreement. The legal consequences would depend on the court’s reasons, the remedy ordered and any subsequent appeal or government response.
A decision against the applicants, on the other hand, could leave the current designation in place, subject to any further legal proceedings.
Until a decision is issued and any applicable changes take effect, the existing STCA rules continue to apply. It would be premature to tell refugee claimants that the agreement has been suspended or that they can now enter Canada from the United States and make a claim without meeting the current requirements.
What should refugee claimants know?
People considering a refugee claim in Canada should obtain reliable legal information before travelling or making decisions about where to seek protection. The STCA is only one part of Canada’s refugee protection framework. Other eligibility rules, admissibility requirements and procedural considerations may also affect a claim.
Individuals should consult official IRCC information and seek advice from an authorized Canadian immigration or refugee law professional where appropriate. They should not rely on social media posts or claims that the court challenge has already changed border rules.
For updates on Canadian immigration policy and available pathways, readers can visit ImmigCanada. Refugee protection matters are fact-specific, and anyone affected should obtain advice based on their individual circumstances.
Frequently Asked Questions
It is an agreement under which most people seeking refugee protection at the Canada-U.S. land border must generally make their claim in the first safe country they reach, subject to specified exceptions.
The applicants argue that returning certain refugee claimants to the United States disproportionately affects racialized women, LGBTQI+ people and children and violates their equality rights under Section 15 of the Charter.
The Supreme Court addressed an earlier stage of the case in 2023 and returned the Section 15 equality questions to the Federal Court for consideration.
Yes. The agreement remains in effect while the current legal challenge proceeds.
Most people entering from the U.S. along the land border are returned unless they qualify for an applicable exception or exemption. Other refugee claim eligibility requirements also apply.
